Dog Collar vs. Harness: Which Is Better?

Collars and harnesses generally serve the same purpose: when paired with a lead, they allow us to direct our dogs and keep them safe from possible danger. However, all dog owners know that getting your pooch to behave well on the leash and not pull can be quite a journey. And let’s be honest - the harness vs. collar dilemma can get confusing. One is not necessarily superior to the other, but both present some key things to consider. Let’s take a closer look, shall we?

Control

First off, one of the most important aspects to consider is how much control you require when walking your furry friend. Generally speaking, dog harnesses offer more control, and this is especially important when it comes to crowded places or busy streets. For instance, if your dog is small or large and strong, you will have better control over the direction and movements with a harness. If your puppy hasn’t learned how to walk on a lead yet, a harness can come in very handy in the training process and prevent him from getting tangled up in the leash. It’s also a great option for dogs who love to pull a disappearing act and wiggle out of the collar.

Risk of Injuries

When it comes to dog collars, there are a few things to keep in mind in regards to your dog’s wellbeing. Firstly, collars can get caught in objects during playtime and even injure the dog. Not only that, but when the leash is pulled, force is applied directly to the dog's neck, which contains vital organs such as the larynx, thyroid, blood vessels, and trachea. Pulling on the leash can pose a risk of injury, whereas a well-fitted harness distributes the pressure across a greater region of the dog's body. This minimises the pressure on the back and prevents potential injuries and health issues.

Comfort

Collars can be more comfortable than harnesses for those dogs that don’t pull or jump around. They also offer a comfortable and secure way to keep ID tags on the dog at all times, which is extremely important in case your dog runs away. Now, when it comes to harnesses, they are usually comfortable for both the dog and the owner. However, if the harness is not well-fitted, it may bring your dog discomfort, as it can cause chaffed skin.

Bottom Line

On the whole, every dog is different and has individual needs that should be met, so only you can decide what’s best for your doggo. That said, if your pup is well-behaved and doesn’t always pull, zig-zag and jump around, a traditional collar is a good option. Storing ID tags is also extremely important, and a collar is a safe and convenient way to do so. However, if your pooch tends to be on the wild side and you need more control when walking or training him, a harness is a better option as it reduces the risk of injuries caused by pulling.